Discussions
Back to Discussions

Ask vs. Axe

Aware-Dragonfly-1857
I just spent 7 weeks of training for work mostly in a classroom environment. I’ve noticed that African Americans in my training would say “Axe” instead of “Ask.” I hope this does not come across as ignorant or anything to that nature but I am genuinely curious as to why that is and maybe the origin of it.

20 comments

frederick_the_duck
It used to be that both pronunciations were quite common. Nowadays, African Americans have preserved axe, and ask has become accepted as the standard. There are still people in England who say axe. It goes way back.
Outrageous_Ad_2752
its just a thing
wvc6969
It’s easier to say axe than ask. Sound changes happen all the time and there isn’t really a “why” other than it was easier.
Bluehawk2008
It's a very long story [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3nysHgnXx-o](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3nysHgnXx-o)
Evil_Weevill
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/African-American_Vernacular_English
JenniferJuniper6
It happens in Ireland too.
SnooDonuts6494
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metathesis_(linguistics)
Elliojam
This is an example of African American Vernacular English which is a dialect found commonly across North America. Some other common aspects of AAVE include but are not limited to: * double negatives * altered conjugation of the copula * omitting the copula * dropping "-ing to" (going to => gonna) There's a lot to learn, but it's worth your time since AAVE is widely used. Often, certain AAVE phrases will become so prevelant that they make their way into popular culture, like the example word, gonna, I used above. It started as AAVE, but is now commonplace is casual English. Here's a guide if you're interested in learning more! https://www.lingoda.com/blog/en/what-is-aave/
Agent__Zigzag
Lots of AAVE things come from the Southern US. And those come from certain regions of the UK where the White settlers lived before coming to America. Saw YouTube video that explained more details linguisticly.
Gravbar
The short of it, is that sometimes sounds swap places. Aks was the original word, but then people started saying ask instead. Both coexisted for a long time but ask became the majority pronunciation and the standard for spelling. African Americans largely preserved the original pronunciation, but other groups did as well, they are just less prominent in media.
PhilArt_of_Andoria
It is also the standard English pronunciation of ask in the year 3000 (according to Futurama).
Jaives
this AAVE phenomenon has actually moved beyond ask/axe. I've encountered it a couple of times on youtube and some documentaries where /sk/ is pronounced /ks/ (ex. "escorted" pronounced as "excorted").
RazarTuk
Yeah, people have been aksing questions for over 1000 years at this point. As in we have a lot of pronunciation spellings from Old English, where people wrote things how they were pronounced, and "acsian" is an attested variant of "ascian". So while "ask" is the *"correct"* form, it's extremely common in certain dialects to "aks" questions instead
-zyxwvutsrqponmlkjih
Different dialect.
bobby__real
I'm from Australia. Axe sounds the same as its spelt like everywhere else..however ask is pronounced more like 'arrrsk'
Fit-Nefariousness354
In nyc we say axe a lot too
PapaOoMaoMao
[Here's](https://youtu.be/7DeWh9UuwMY?si=S_u5SXiANK0Jnhzu) a good video about it.
ausecko
They used to be interchangeable hundreds of years ago (ask and aks), but I think the modern use is a resurgence unrelated to that, stemming from some accents just making it a more natural way of saying it?
MakePhilosophy42
Its "aks"(ask) not "axe". In some accents theres an audible difference between them. Thats an alternative pronunciation for ask. Very common in certain accents. Instead of the /sk/ sound after the *A* its a /ks/ sound
maxthed0g
Axe is incorrect pronunciation. The axe pronunciation would be correct if the "k" and the "s" in the word "ASK", were reversed, resulting in a new word "AKS." There is no reason I know to reverse those letters.